MOOP!

My star ratings, from five to one, generally mean outstanding, excellent, good, fair, and poor. I think something equivalent to your system would be albums with a majority of songs having four or five stars, but I think there are quite a lot of those. So, just the ones that have a majority with five stars:

"Rain, Hail, or Shine" by Battlefield Band - 5/9
"Abbey Road" by the Beatles - 9/17
"Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band" by the Beatles - 9/13
"1" by the Beatles¹ - 15/27
"Tubthumper" by Chumbawamba - 6/12²
"Drum, Hat, Buddha" by Dave Carter and Tracy Grammer - 8/12
"Crossing the Bridge" by Eileen Ivers - 7/12
"Lemonade & Buns" by Kíla - 8/11
"Get Lost" by The Magnetic Fields - 7/13
"Automatic For The People" by R.E.M. - 8/12
"Eponymous" by R.E.M. - 12/12³
"Sasquatch" by Sixteen Feet - 7/13
"Imaginary Tartan Menagerie" by the Tartan Amoebas - 7/9⁴
"Tartan Amoebas" by the Tartan Amoebas - 6/10
"WhirlyGig" by WhirlyGig - 7/10

1. Not sure if this should count, since it's kind of a greatest hits.
2. Not strictly a majority, but it also has no songs rated less than four stars, so.
3. Also a best of, but still. So awesome.
4. Obligatory Star Trek: Voyager reference here.